Mother Teresa Should Not Have Been Declared a Saint?

Mother Teresa Should Not Have been declared a saint?



2019 update: I wrote this article a few years ago and although there is no longer the uproar at her canonization, I still occasionally see some skepticism and comments stating that Mother Teresa should not have been declared a Saint.

Nothing is more frustrating to me these days than seeing the constant posts and commentary against the canonization of Mother Teresa of Calcutta. Are there people who seriously believe that Mother Teresa should not have been declared a Saint? On what authority is this determination made?

In this audio, I explain why we need to focus on other things – not whether she should have been canonized or not.

Mother Teresa, born Agnes Bojaxhiu in Albania,  was a nun who devoted her life to serving the sick and suffering in India. Mother Teresa’s life changed when she received a “call within a call”.

“For years, Mother Teresa refused to talk about this seminal moment in her life. But worldwide interest in her “call within a call” would not diminish. Reluctantly, she spoke about it. “God was calling me to give up all and to surrender myself to him in the service of the poorest of the poor in the slums.”
The call happened on September 10, 1946, as she traveled by train from Calcutta to Darjeeling. Suddenly, a new mission presented itself. “To fail would have been to break the faith,” she said.”

She spent her life working with the “undesirables”: the poor, the orphans and the helpers.  Here is a good site if you’d like to learn more about her.


Canonization Objection: She Did Not Evangelize Those She Served

There is a quote that is being passed around where Mother Teresa says:

“There is only one God and He is God to all; therefore it is important that everyone is seen as equal before God. Ive always said that we should help a Hindu become a better Hindu, a Muslim become a better Muslim, a Catholic become a better Catholic.”

Some say that makes her a relativist, but did it occur to anyone that she was working in an environment that was often hostile to Christians? In fact, the government of India accused her of prosyletizing under the guise of helping the poor. Maybe she said that so that everyone would be comfortable coming to her for help. I don’t know. However, these other two quotes convince me that was, in fact,  sharing the good news of the Gospel of Jesus Christ.

“When we do ‘our work,’ visiting the families, teaching the children, nursing the sick, helping the dying, gathering the little children for church, we should do it with one aim in view: ‘the salvation of the poor.’ We want to bring them to Jesus and bring Jesus to them.”
“We have to carry our Lord to places where he has not walked before. Therefore the sisters must be consumed with one desire: Jesus. Speak of no one but him crucified. We must not be afraid to do the things he did – to go fearless thoroughly death and danger with him and for him.”

Mother Teresa left behind a CATHOLIC order of almost 5,000 sisters in fact – sisters who are continuing to shine a light on Catholic religious orders and our faith.

The fact is the canonization has been completed. We need to focus on saving our souls and that of our families instead of debating whether the Church erred in declaring Mother Teresa a Saint.

We need to focus on becoming saints ourselves!

What do you think of this debate?

This article and audio were originally published in 2016.


More on Mother Teresa

If you purchase through our site links, we might get a commission, at no extra cost to you. Your support helps us keep this site going. Thank you!

8 thoughts on “Mother Teresa Should Not Have Been Declared a Saint?

  1. Anonymous

    The future will be even kinder to her when we find out how many sisters are quietly and humbly doing much the same things that she did.

    Looking forward to the day when some of her successors are named as venerable, blessed or Saints.

    Reply
  2. Kevin

    Great Video, I believe you have given the best solution to this issue (or , I should say non issue ) to many other items to focus on. I personally do not feel that I am qualified to judge anyone.
    Thank you for your brilliant video post

    Reply
  3. Leon

    Right on point! Excellent counter quotes! There’s a lot people throwing shade at Mother Theresa because she was an excellent witness and they want to throw accusations to quell what her witness is saying to them and others around them. We just have to pray for them.

    Reply
  4. Nicholas

    To the author: The written portion of this article contains contradictory claims and evidence. Teresa of Calcutta no doubt was called to help the poor; however, the debated question is not wether she helped the poor, or had a calling to do so, but wether she is in Heaven or the evidence lacks in one or more areas to prove she is indeed in heaven and not in Purgatory or Hell. The second quote provides evidence of what you call possible relativity; I choose to call the quote exactly what it is, heresy. One cannot help a member of a false religion endeavor to improve in what Catholics know to be untrue, by virtue of the Eighth Commandment. Additionally this is called modernism, an illegal concept that would allow the church to change its doctrine after it’s set. An example would be the “reforms” made by Martin Luther during the Protestant Schism.

    I attempt to objectively show facts in most of my writing; however, you have found a gray area. One can try to defend that quote, and yet when faced with the facts I have fifteen theologians, thirty saints, and 260 Supreme Pontiffs I can think of off the top of my head who have said otherwise.

    It is not our place to defend the canonization of a person, because we are imperfect. You might think I am rude or ill mannered, and yet, what I just did, is called the “Devil’s Advocate” position. It’s the priest, or often times a bishop, who attempts to find a flaw in proposed arguments. They prevent thousands of people from ever reaching sainthood, because we do not have enough proof of their sainthood. And as you saw, I was able to do intense damage without getting my theology books out and really hammering the nail. The consideration now is wether or not this canonization is infallible or fallible? Are sedevecantists correct?

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.